Watersheds
Messenger Fall 2007 Vol.
XIV, No. 2
PDF ISSUE |
BACK |
Book Review: Western Turf Wars:
The Politics of Public Lands Ranching (2007) by Mike Hudak
Reviewed by Todd Shuman, WWP Advisory Board member
|
|
This book, which is based upon video-taped interviews of retired agency
scientists, land managers, non-government scientists, and conservationists, presents a
wealth of valuable historical information through the stories of 27 people who have
been resisting abusive livestock grazing management practices on public lands. Four
of the people interviewed in the book are currently associated with WWP (Ralph
Maughan, Julian Hatch, Larry Walker, and Todd Shuman).
The range of issues, regions, concerns, and historical periods addressed in the
book is immense. From Martha Hahn, we hear about the battles to transform BLM
grazing management in Idaho in the 1990s. From Douglas Barber, Leon Fager, and
Renee Galeano-Popp, we receive blow-by-blow accounts of reform and counter-reform
within the Apache-Sitgreaves and Lincoln National Forests while Mike Sauber lays out the campaign to
stop the construction of massive stock tanks in the Aldo Leopold Wilderness of the Gila National Forest.
Julian Hatch and Patrick Diehl lay out the political economy of livestock grazing in the Grand Staircase-
Escalante National Monument while also reminding us of the chilling consequences rural grazing reform
activists face when challenging the status quo. Ralph Maughan then presents us with a most concise,
informative overview of issues and facts concerning bison and wolf "control" in the Northern Rockies.
When we get a hankering for some hard-core science, we can turn to Clait Braun for the lowdown on
the history and science behind efforts to protect the Gunnison sage grouse, as well as for a detailed
critique of a western states conservation assessment of "Greater Sage-grouse and Sagebrush Habitats" that
needed "holes . . . to be shot in it." Different interviews address livestock-related issues concerning Hart
Mountain NAR, the grasslands of the Black Hills, Malheur NWR, pygmy rabbit habitat in Washington, the
Golden Trout Wilderness, among many others.
Hudak gently "prodded" his subjects to recount the events, conflicts, and perceptions that prompted
them to address livestock-on-public-land issues in the first place. Buy it and start "mining" it for the
unusual history and accumulated wisdom that it contains.
Western Turf Wars can be purchased over the Internet at http://westernturfwars.com or by contacting
Mike Hudak directly at Biome Books, 38 Oliver Street, Binghamton, NY 13904-1516. You can
also call 607.330.0351.