Watersheds Messenger Summer 2001 Vol. VIII, No. 2 PDF ISSUE |
|
Return of the Native: WWP's Greenfire Preserve |
In
his essay "Thinking Like A Mountain," Aldo Leopold tells the story of a time
when he worked for the Forest Service in Arizona. He and his crew spotted several wolves
by a river and took aim on the pack. After the shooting, Leopold recalls reaching an old
female wolf "in time to watch a fierce green fire dying in her eyes."
"I
realized then," Leopold wrote, "and have known ever since, that there was
something new to me in those eyes - something known only to her and the mountain."
In
the spirit of Leopold's revelation and essay, Western Watershed Project's Greenfire
Preserve is being restored to its native state on the East Fork of the Salmon River.
Many
WWP members aren't familiar with our activities at Greenfire, and some not even with its
origins, so I think it's appropriate to start from the beginning. In June 2000, a
conservationist and friend of WWP purchased a 440-acre former ranch along the East Fork,
and a management agreement was reached with WWP, then Idaho Watersheds Project. As WWP's
Central Idaho director, I assumed the duties of preserve manager and moved to the property
on Sept. 1.
Initially,
WWP directors and administrators drew up four
Another
short-term objective was to meet with various agencies to build relationships with
potential partners who might help us in our restoration efforts.
Long-term
objectives include: restoring Greenfire to a selfsustaining preserve of native habitat
and retiring three U.S. Forest Service and three BLM grazing permits attached to the
property; creating an education center where people
can learn about properly functioning native habitat, and where universities and their
students can use the property for seminars and research projects; making Greenfire available for conferences and visits by
the media.
September-October
We
had problems transferring the BLM grazing permits right off the bat. The previous owner
had signed over the Bradshaw Basin permit to another grazing permittee. Eventually, the
permit was transferred to Valley Sun.
We
met with various state and federal agencies, including the Natural
Resources Conservation Service, Model Watersheds Project, Bonneville Power Administration,
Sho-Ban Tribes and Idaho Department of Fish and Game. The meetings consisted of property
tours and discussions to initiate restoration projects. For its part, NRCS stepped up to
the plate and offered to share costs for a planting project.
Because all livestock was removed from
the property, we submitted a proposal to the Model Watersheds Project to relocate the
jack-and-pole fencing along the riparian corridor as a replacement for the barbed-wire
perimeter fence on the property. Jack-and-pole fencing is far more wildlife-friendly. Our
proposal was denied, but we will continue to seek funding for this project.
There are five pivots that irrigate the
majority of the property. Three of the pivots travel in a circle; two move in a
semicircle. They are computer-controlled and can be programmed to do just about anything
(when they aren't stuck in wheel ruts or knocked out of commission by any number of
mechanical or electrical nightmares).
The more we learned about the
property, the more we became concerned about the
November-December
On the weekend of Nov. 4, we held an open
house attended by about 60 WWP members and friends. Master chef Claire Casey cooked and
choreographed yet another memorable feast.
It occurred to us that no place this
special - a place now free of livestock - should be called a ranch, and we appealed to the
gathered guests for help. To set the mood, I read "Thinking Like A Mountain"
from Leopold's A Sand County Almanac. The essay reflects the values we want to
bestow on the preserve, so we kept it in mind as we considered a suitable name. Greenfire,
submitted by Ralph Maughn, struck a chord with all of us.
Later in November, we learned about BPA's
high-priority projects. I met with BPA and IDFG representatives to determine if retirement
of the Salmon River Breaks allotment would fit the criteria of these projects and if the
agencies would support such a proposal.
The Salmon River Breaks is one of several
allotments attached to the Greenfire property, and our suggestion was met enthusiastically
by BPA. We drafted a proposal, which met with support from BPA and every other federal
agency we contacted except the U.S. Forest Service. Even the BLM, who administers part of
the allotment, was behind the proposal. We spent a good part of the next three months
trying to convince the USFS of the merits of our proposal, but the issue was too
politically charged for the agency to endorse. Postscript to the story: They haven't seen
the last of us yet.
January
In January, Bill and Josephine Lowe
generously donated a four-wheel-drive Ford 250 pickup truck to WWP Since then, I've
discovered that Greenfire probably couldn't operate at its
February
In February, a crew was brought in to
remove fences on the property. The group soon became our planting crew as well. From
February to mid-April, the workers carried out what some in the Challis area would
consider heresy. They removed crossfences and corrals from Greenfire. During an
Experimental Stewardship meeting in Challis, one rancher who used to work at the property
when it was a cattle ranch told me, "It really gave me heartburn to see you tearing
out those corrals. It took me a whole day to put some of those posts in." "If it
makes you feel any better," I replied, "we wore out two new handyman jacks just
getting the posts out of the ground."
March
In March, Judy Hall prepared and
submitted two grant applications: an EPA 319 proposal and an application to the National
Fish and Wildlife Foundation for a Five-Star Restoration Challenge Grant. The proposals
are for restoration projects on Greenfire and the state-owned section along Lake Creek,
for which WWP holds the grazing lease.
Meanwhile, while fence removal continued
at Greenfire, I went on a tour of the East Fork and Upper Salmon River with Mark Olson to
locate areas where cottonwood and willow cuttings could be gathered. Locating an area
suitable for collection is difficult due to degraded river systems that seldom flood (a
natural and necessary process) and livestock grazing that is destroying most of the
limited regeneration. There are cottonwoods to be found, but most of them are mature and
often decadent.
April
In April, BLM authorized WWP to collect
cottonwood and willow cuttings, and we spent seven days collecting cuttings and preparing
them according to a planting guide provided by NRCS.
On April 23, a backhoe arrived and
planting began. The cuttings were small cottonwoods and willow stalks measuring more than
8 feet.
We planted more than 300 cottonwood
cuttings, upwards of 150 willow bundles and 500 cottonwood nursery stock. More than 90
percent of the willow cuttings and 75 percent of the cottonwoods are showing new leaves.
Also in April, we presented the EPA 319
grant proposal to the Basin Advisory Group and Watershed Advisory Group. At both
presentations, livestock interests showed their true colors. Their opposition was long on
politics and personal bias, and short on facts about water quality. We await word on the
grant and believe we have an excellent chance to be funded.
May
Early in May, WWP was visited by
more angels. Gordon and Jennifer Younger donated a Ford Explorer to the Greenfire cause.
Their gift has been a huge benefit for Greenfire projects and for our work throughout
central Idaho.
We know what we want to do at
Greenfire, and we are looking for successful models. In May, we decided it would be
beneficial to bring in consultants from Bitterroot Restoration to help establish a plan
and budget for the restoration of Greenfire.
Also in May, we put the
irrigation systems into shape and began watering the hay fields at Greenfire. If we don't
irrigate prior to the restoration of native species, we stand a good chance of seeing the
fields consumed by exotic weed species - weeds that are difficult to eliminate. We also
need to irrigate in order to keep our water right and grow forage for native wildlife.
June
We received funding from WWP
contributors to bring Bitterroot Restoration consultants to Greenfire, and a schedule was
set. The director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Habitat Restoration Funding also
toured the property and expressed interest in a partnership.
Also in June, we received word
that WWP's application for the Five-Star Restoration Challenge Grant was successful. The
$8,100 award gives us another source for more restoration efforts and can serve as
matching funds for other grant proposals.
We continued to irrigate through
June, but not without problems and significant expenses. Equipment breakdowns were
July
By July 12, the grass at
Greenfire was waist-high in places, so the pivots were shut down. The hand and wheel
irrigation lines continue to operate, but the irrigation program in general clearly
demonstrates that a natural, self-sustaining system is far better for all involved: WWP,
wildlife and natural systems.
Resistance to Greenfire is keen
in some corners. Livestock interests have attempted to block WWP's grant proposals.
Inflammatory signs have been posted on Greenfire fence posts. Opponents have even resorted
to littering the driveway with nails, resulting in a rash of flat tires. I think some
interests fear we're going to open the eyes of the public. With any luck, we may do just
that.
For years, WWP has fought to have
exclosures established to demonstrate the potential for watersheds and uplands recovery.
With the Greenfire preserve, we have an ideal opportunity to show what can happen to
public lands when livestock grazing is eliminated. And with all the allotments tied to the
Greenfire property, we can show the same results on nearly 50,000 acres of federal lands.
In Greenfire, we also have the
authority to acquire more grazing permits and attach them to the preserve for retirement.
Our long-term goal at Greenfire is to create a living model that we and others can learn
from. For this to happen, we need only to look to our name for inspiration and guidance in
our restoration decisions.
Greenfire. May it always remind
us to think like a mountain.